Discontinued Bullets

Modern Muzzleloading Forum

Help Support Modern Muzzleloading Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

DESPERATE LEE

Well-Known Member
*
Joined
Dec 11, 2019
Messages
301
Reaction score
326
For those who love the Hornady Great Plains bullets, Deer Creek Products has some left. In 45 cal they have at least 10 boxes of the 285 gr HBHP, in 50 cal they have at least 10 boxes of 385 gr HBHP, in 410 gr HBFP ( my favorite ) i bought the last of them, and in 54 cal they have at least 20 boxes of 425 gr HBHP or so they say. Prices from $11.45 to $11.95 to $12.20 per box. Just thought i would let people know . Now if i can find some 275 gr TC Maxi Hunters i would be set for years to come. You guys got any loads for these you wish to share? I shoot TC Hawken 50 cal in 1-48 twist and Traditions inline with 1-32 twist.
DL
 
Finding .50 275 gr Maxi Hunters isn't a problem, its the price per 20 that's the issue. They cost almost double what you'd pay for Great plains bullets.
 
I wish Buffalo Bullets were still being made, closest I can find is Hornady PA Conical
 
I agree there Retiredusn. I use the PA's in my 50 cal CVA Mountain pistol. They work pretty good. Never got a chance to use the Buffalo Ballets.
DL
 
I wish Buffalo Bullets were still being made, closest I can find is Hornady PA Conical
What caliber? I have a couple boxes of .45 285 I’d let go for next to nothing. Lube is all dried up. They would need boiled and re-lubed. That would be a TOUGH mold to create. Not sure it would even be possible. You would probably have to swage either the hollow point or the hollow base into it and create some sort of knurling contraption to put the knurl onto it.
 
Thanks for the offer, I use the .50 cal and the PA conical has done well for me.
 
I have a few .50 cal not sure how many. Less than a full box of 20. If you want them, they actually might be Hornady Great Plains. They’re in a red plastic box. I’ll look at them in the a.m. I don’t shoot them so whoever wants to cough up the shipping can have them.
 
I have about 250 PR bullets .50 cal 450gr. spitzer conicals. I guess they don't make them anymore. If someone needs a few I would be glad to share maybe 150 of them.
 
This situation comes about because suppliers won't make bullets that aren't selling at a pace where it makes economic sense to manufacture them. That comes about because of fewer people shooting muzzleloaders/black powder. Long term solution is get more people into shooting muzzleloaders. Short term solution is learn to cast and get a mold. You'll never be out of bullets then.
 
Finding .50 275 gr Maxi Hunters isn't a problem, its the price per 20 that's the issue. They cost almost double what you'd pay for Great plains bullets.

The other BIG Factor, at least for me personally, is Quality Control of the TC Maxi Hunters and Their Maxi Balls. Not only are they Expensive, most of them i have seen/Bought were Pathetic at best. Wrinkles from cold mold/contaminate, Pin holes in bases, Etc. The TC Bullets are Cast. The Hornady Bullets are Swaged, you will find the Quality of the Hornady Bullets to be FAR & AWAY Superior to The TC Cast Bullets. Cast Bullets have to be METICULOUSLY Cast to Compete with Swaged. I can DEFINITELY cast a Bullet as good as ANY swaged Bullet Out there, But it’s taken a Lot of Practice, Trial/Error to Get there.
 
I have considered pouring my own in the past but I don't need another hobby. Per this forum there are still some good lead bullet manufacturers as well as bullet/sabot combinations out there. I do like the idea of designing and pouring my own though. Frankly I don't have the knowledge like some of the people here. I have thought of buying a mold and having a company or person pour them for me. Buy as stated there are good bullets out there.
In the fall I hunt pheasants and occasionally geese and ducks. Deer are a given from November 15-Jan 1. I don't do archery anymore cause I don't have time. In the winter I do coyote and fox. In a few weeks I go to Arkansas to hunt pigs. In the spring I hunt turkey and in summer I like to cruise for groundhogs. I reload rifle and shoot 300-400 a year. Love to take my guns out and shoot paper in the nice weather. Oh, and then there is the trout fishing. My real passion. At every opportunity. Something peaceful about standing in a brookie stream and trying to coax one out.
I now have two grandchildren and babysit 1 of them 1 day a week. Hes 6 months old. I wouldn't trade that for all the guns and ammo on the planet. Bought a .177 pellet gun the other day. With that I can just sit in the yard to cut paper and kill squirrels and it takes but a few moments.
I believe reloading your own is a precise hobby and unless a guy has appropriate time to give to it he will be disappointed or dead. Making your own bullets probably falls into the category like reloading. Do it right or waste your time.
Didn't mean to get preachy on this. I figure Im like everybody else. Time is limited and you have to pick and choose how you spend your time. I think there is or will be an opportunity out there for a fellow to design and pour bullets for fellows like us. If not already then in the future. And that fellow will have more knowledge now than I will accumulate on this subject in my remaining years.
 
Same reason I reload my own rifle cartridges. I can customize the components and precisely reload to get fine accuracy. Better than a machine banging out 100 per stroke. Ill bet a paycheck on the average the fellows here who pour there own have much better quality than the mass produced ones.
 
[/QUOTE]That comes about because of fewer people shooting muzzleloaders/black powder. Long term solution is get more people into shooting muzzleloaders. Short term solution is learn to cast and get a mold. You'll never be out of bullets then.[/QUOTE]



OK, so here comes a ramble that eventually gets back on topic. First off, your comment about “shooting” spot on,
Back when Utah, in an effort to increase fawn production, moved the ML Hunt from the first week of November (the rut) to the last week of September, the number of ML hunters exploded. When it was in November, you could hunt the whole thing and see maybe 10-20 other hunters. With it in September, you see 10 other hunters in every place you go. So the popularity has increased, at least here. In saying that, I only personally know three people, including myself, who shoot big lead bullets, Everyone else traded their Hawkens, Renegades, Whites, Gonics, etc... in for guns “specially designed” to shoot pellets and sabots, and PowerBelts. I admit, I myself fell for that too. Ran right out and bought an Encore When they came out. Pellets were the best marketed addition to muzzleloading I ever had heard of, and a gun that could shoot 150 grains? WOW! I’ll be making 3-400 yard shots in no time. Boy was I disappointed. I didn’t trade a gun in though to buy that rifle. We were working in Vegas and I saved my per-diem and small gambling winnings, I would put $10 in quarters through a video poker machine, two at a time, cash it out after the last two quarters went in, and go put it in my bag. Gave me time for a couple of complimentary drinks, and most nights a buck or two more than I started with, and I wanted that Encore! I only traded one ML to get another one that same TC Encore, I saved for 3-4 months to buy, and a couple hundred bucks for a Savage, and here is the reason why: I was hunting with it and had hit a nice four point mule deer and he didn’t go down. Turns out, I needed a second, and third, and fourth shot to anchor him. He was hit pretty hard and was just walking away, but if he got up and over the saddle he was moving through, the other side was a deep canyon, that I had no desire to haul him up and out of, so I was hurrying. The second shot I was pretty nervous he was getting away and whiffed. That third shot, loaded hard as hell until I got almost to my witness mark and then it went super easy, I wonder now if I pushed the bullet through the back of the sabot. I have no idea where that shot went. So I’m sitting out on the side of the hill, while this buck is walking away, trying to get enough spit on a patch to facilitate cleaning my gun to get the fourth shot to go down the barrel and shoot somewhat accurately. I dropped him with that shot. Over the next couple of years, I would guess, I was trying everything to get accuracy and a smooth loading second and third shot. I couldn’t find the right combo back then, never even tried conicals out of that gun, it was marketed as a pellet, sabot gun, and that’s what I wanted to shoot, anybody still shooting big slow moving bullets was too dumb to see how great this was and was still living in the dark ages...stupid of me. I got so frustrated with it that I got rid of the gun, kinda kicking myself now. BH 209 didn’t exist then and would have changed that whole situation for me. Now, thanks to a lot of you guys on this forum talking about worn out breech plugs, I’ve got my Whites shooting like they did when they were new, and I don’t think I will ever Hunt with another rifle other than them. Most of the people I have told about how I solved my accuracy problems, can’t believe that was a problem, a bigger hole gets more flame into the powder making a lot more complete ignition, right? That’s what I thought. Boy was I wrong again..I was getting so frustrated with my Whites, I was about to sell the whole lot of them too.
That may also be a contributing factor to moving away from big bullets, gun starts shooting like crap so you buy the latest, greatest.
The problem i see is most of the sporting goods stores cater to what’s popular, and only what’s popular. You can’t find real black powder within 300 maybe 400 miles of here. Finding big lead conical bullets is harder than ever now too, except online. You can still get Maxi Balls and I think I have seen some Great Plains bullets, but they are few and far between. Most everything is geared to sabots, pellets, and now BH209, which I think is the best innovation in this sport yet, but just one more thing driving people away from heavy lead bullets. Even with more of the population (much more) geared to shoot sabots, there is a pretty poor selection of those around out here (some of the bullets that are available now, I would never have heard of, had it not been for this forum). There again, they carry what’s popular, forcing us to shop online. I hate to wait for bullets, or anything for that matter, to come in the mail. When I want something, I want it now! I want to go to the store and buy it, right then.
I build my own molds and cast my own bullets for my slug guns, it lets me tweak some of the bullet designs I like, to make them my own, and there’s a lot of satisfaction in designing, building, and casting with a self made mold, when you see three of those bullets go inside an inch.
All this nonsense has opened the door for a small casting operation to become somewhat profitable, But I bet if you talk to Dan and Dave, they do it because they enjoy it and it puts a couple of bucks in their pocket, not because they are becoming millionaires at it.
I think most people only get their guns out a couple of days before the opener, take a couple of shots to make sure everything is still good and that’s it. That doesn’t lead to a lot of bullet sales. Out of all the guys I know personally that hunt with a ML, I am the only one who “shoots” one. I shoot them all year long. Even if I’m going out to shoot the Barrett, I bring along a .22 for the grandkids, and a ML. I think most of us on this forum, shoot all year long and go through a lot of powder and bullets, but we are a super small percentage of the ML hunters out there.
So yeah, your comment about getting more people “shooting” muzzleloaders. Spot on!
 
The other BIG Factor, at least for me personally, is Quality Control of the TC Maxi Hunters and Their Maxi Balls. Not only are they Expensive, most of them i have seen/Bought were Pathetic at best. Wrinkles from cold mold/contaminate, Pin holes in bases, Etc. The TC Bullets are Cast. The Hornady Bullets are Swaged, you will find the Quality of the Hornady Bullets to be FAR & AWAY Superior to The TC Cast Bullets. Cast Bullets have to be METICULOUSLY Cast to Compete with Swaged. I can DEFINITELY cast a Bullet as good as ANY swaged Bullet Out there, But it’s taken a Lot of Practice, Trial/Error to Get there.

Hey Lew, Do you remember this picture of a TC bullet I found in a box?

8IHXraA.jpg
 
For those who love the Hornady Great Plains bullets, Deer Creek Products has some left. In 45 cal they have at least 10 boxes of the 285 gr HBHP, in 50 cal they have at least 10 boxes of 385 gr HBHP, in 410 gr HBFP ( my favorite ) i bought the last of them, and in 54 cal they have at least 20 boxes of 425 gr HBHP or so they say. Prices from $11.45 to $11.95 to $12.20 per box. Just thought i would let people know . Now if i can find some 275 gr TC Maxi Hunters i would be set for years to come. You guys got any loads for these you wish to share? I shoot TC Hawken 50 cal in 1-48 twist and Traditions inline with 1-32 twist.
DL

When I got wind that Hornady was going to stop production of the 410 gr 50 cal I bought everything I could find. over 40 boxes. I had a gun that liked them a bunch and then I set out to make my own. After a couple years I developed my paper patched Lee 500 S&W bullet and load. Then I sold all 40 boxes for almost twice what I payed for them.
 
Hey Lew, Do you remember this picture of a TC bullet I found in a box?

8IHXraA.jpg

:roll: I do remember this Ron!! I have actually talked about this Particular bullet before :D How in the Hell did that thing get Packaged/Boxed up and Not Get Noticed??? I have found the Store Bought TC Maxi Ball/Maxi Hunters to be Some of the Worst i have seen, Poor Fill out, Wrinkles from a Contaminant or Cool Mold, Holes in the Bases, Etc. It is REALLY disappointing when you Purchase a Box of Bullets and Have to CULL Back half or More of them, THIS IS WHY I CAST MY OWN :lewis: It puts ME in Control of What i load in My Rifles

Good to See you Post Ron!! QUIT being a Stranger!!!!
 
:roll: I do remember this Ron!! I have actually talked about this Particular bullet before :D How in the Hell did that thing get Packaged/Boxed up and Not Get Noticed??? I have found the Store Bought TC Maxi Ball/Maxi Hunters to be Some of the Worst i have seen, Poor Fill out, Wrinkles from a Contaminant or Cool Mold, Holes in the Bases, Etc. It is REALLY disappointing when you Purchase a Box of Bullets and Have to CULL Back half or More of them, THIS IS WHY I CAST MY OWN :lewis: It puts ME in Control of What i load in My Rifles

Good to See you Post Ron!! QUIT being a Stranger!!!!

Life has changed so much for me I am almost not the same guy I was a year ago.
I fell off the ladder at work, had surgery, and when I was supposed to go back I couldn't walk. I retired from the feed mill and prepared my self to work for Kama at the daycare. I was offered a job as the grounds keeper at the cemetery. I took it and have just been enjoying my self.
A week ago Kama's dad passed away and that once again turned our life's up side down.
Seems like I am just presented with life hurdles every day.
 
Well i went back to Deer Creek Products and turns out they found 20 more boxes of the 410 gr 50 cal Hornady Great Plains. Who knows how many they have rat holed in the warehouse. I have over 100 bullets now so should do me a while.
DL
 
Those 50 410gr were the best that Hornady offered. I could have sworn they are not HP, just hollow base.

Yep, flat point
b7951051-79b1-46d7-9f65-a4932a354401-jpeg.4499
 
Last edited:

Latest posts

Back
Top