.451 volunteer keyholes

Modern Muzzleloading Forum

Help Support Modern Muzzleloading Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Joined
Apr 5, 2020
Messages
28
Reaction score
40
So I have been trying to develop a load for my knight ul 45. I picked up some baco .451 450gr volunteers in 1/20 alloy first time I went out I only was able to shoot 5 over 70 gr v goex 2 f all seemed to punch clean holes. The second time I went out I started to have problems with key holes and unable to put a group together still the 70 gr v charge. Today I went out with weighed charges in 70 75 80 gr 5 each and still the problem persisted. I did size some of them down to .4505 to make loading easier. From what I've researched these should be stable any ideas I'm all ears.
 
Prolly needs a over powder wad?
 
If you are thinking the bullet is too long to stabilize, try a shorter bullet and see if it straightens up.
Do you have any .460 wads to try and see if that helps? I never tried 50 cal wads in a 45, just thinking they may fold over and not seal
 
At the 3 Minute Mark I explain it. For demonstration purposes I used an Old .54 Barrel that doesn’t have a Breech Plug, i was using OVERSIZE .58 Cal Wool felt Wads. It’s the Same EXACT procedure using a .50 Cal Wool Felt Wad in a .45 Bore

 
Wad was my 1st thought, but your using one..
What lube are you using and with that, have you seen any evidence of leading?

The 1:20 is certainly fast enough to stabilize that bullet.
 
1-20 should easily stabilize a 450gr lead bullet.

Wild guess....your alloy is too hard for such a light load of powder. Try sizing them .001-.002 over land size. This will probably require you swab after each shot but they should still load on a clean or semi clean bore. You could also try "pre engraving" them on a clean bore. Push them in a couple inches then back out. Make a small mark inline with the front sight or mark at the muzzle so you load them the same way later.
 
I had the same issue several years ago with the Whitworth bullet (475 grains) and a 1-18 twist barrel using 50 grains of powder. I was shooting in a league and was given a large quantity of lead with a unknown hardness ,so I poured several hundred bullets for practice and league shooting. These bullets shot fantastic until about the 3rd week and then started hitting the target sideways at 25 yards. That's when I learned about " age hardening " and not letting the bullet bump up to fill the grooves.This doesn't happen with pure lead and I've never heard it happen with lead/tin alloys but if there is any antimony in the mix, that's when you will have issues. Not wanting to waste this lead I melted them down and cast only what I thought I would use on a weekly basis.
 
1-20 should easily stabilize a 450gr lead bullet.

Wild guess....your alloy is too hard for such a light load of powder. Try sizing them .001-.002 over land size. This will probably require you swab after each shot but they should still load on a clean or semi clean bore. You could also try "pre engraving" them on a clean bore. Push them in a couple inches then back out. Make a small mark inline with the front sight or mark at the muzzle so you load them the same way later.
I was wondering if the hardness might have something to do with it. The bullets I found in the backstop don't show any rifling.
 
. The bullets I found in the backstop don't show any rifling.
I know guys shooting bullets harder than 1:20 - do you have the ability to test a bullets hardness?
Really surprised if BACO sent out bad bullets, not as described.
If no rifling - Knuckleball
 
I was wondering if the hardness might have something to do with it. The bullets I found in the backstop don't show any rifling.
if they didn't show rifling you are way under and they never bumped and are you wiping between shots
 

Latest posts

Back
Top