Well Chuck if you are going for pure accuracy for under 800 yds, I would shoot the 168, it is a tack driver especially at 600 yds. A good rifle/shooter combo will actually go under 4 inchs from the belly with that load. No doubt you can shoot that, it is just getting the right gun and a little practice. If you want max performance from a 308 at 100 yds, you might go with the 175, as Doohan reminded me the other day on the phone, the 175 stays super sonic out to 1000 where the 168 does not. Now I need to verify that statement but it is an important one. At 1000 yds the 168 is tough to shoot well. It can be done and I have had some real good days at 1000 with it, but I have also had days were I was scratching my bean as it just seemed to be floating all over, and I was off call, regardless of wind.
Matter of fact I see no advantage to the civilain shooter to go with the 308 as a tactical rifle for 1000 yd shooting. The need for mult shots, recoil tolerance, ammo interchangibility are just not there. If you can shoot a 308 at 1000 well, you can shoot anything there ( in context of course). But the magnums really do outshine the 308 at long distance, with a much better angle of attack, reduced flight time, and less wind drift. They of course have more recoil ( how much depends on weight of gun, etc, but todays tactical rifles run heavy and a good brake makes them pleasant) and barrel life is shorter ( bunch of hoeey abounds here, I will tell you that you can real world expect 2000 rds or better from a 300 win mag and 5000 rds or better from a 308, set back the chamber and get another 1000 rds from both on avg, most " experts" claim less, but that is hooey)
and the ammo cost more. But it is a tactical, not a assault rifle, and if you are gonna spend big bucks on a rifle scope combo worth the time to train behind, ammo cost is the last thing I would consider.
If I bought another tactical rifle, it would be a real heavy dude about 15lbs, in 300 RUM or something similar, with a nasty loud brake, and a big ole nightforce scope. It would be 1500 yd capable at the least.
A size up and I would go with a 50 BMG or probably one of the newer wildcats with ridiculous BC's of better the 1.0 ( not a typo there boyz,they make'em).
For a huntin rig, maybe something about 13 lbs in 7 RUM or similar would be an awesome choice.
Okay, If I win the powerball I will get one of each! You talked me into it!