Ive seen more varied opinions and arguments over broadhead than any bullet "fave" discussion. I have used many over the years, but personally I shy away from expandibles. I dont believe in moving parts on a projectile, and follow the theory, of simple= less chance for failure. For the last decade or so, I have been using Montec G5. They are almost indestructable, easily resharpened and reusable. My #1 arrow has been through 4 deer and a coyote now. I just resharpen and its all ready to go. It IS in its second arrow. I believe people like to blame the arrow (bullet) many times for a rushed or bad shot. I use the same broadhead for both compound, and recurve bows. The recurve arrows just have weighted inserts in the tip also. In reality, most any quality broadhead is fine, shot placement is probably more important. Just be aware where you buy them, and exactly what they are. Most popular heads have a chinese knockoff counterpart, with much inferior materials. I believe a LOT of the negative reviews on these things are due to buying the cheap knockoffs. ( most are packaged and labeled to mimic the originals) Just be aware if you purchase through amazon or similar, and who the vendor is. Usually that great deal price, isnt really such a great deal in reality..