Rick said:
First I want to say welcome to the forum.
Second, I would recommend trying BH209. Get rid of the pellet/stick powder and go loose. Never had good luck with JSG, my personal opinion of that stuff I can't say here without getting in trouble.
To each his own.....I am still testing out JSG, but so far I am impressed. The 5 things I look at in order:
1. Ignition, if ignition is poor or inconsistent, game over, what good is a ML that won't fire, or inconsistent..
2. Accuracy. Ya gotta be able to hit what your aiming at. Being a reloader, I know it takes some tweaking in powder charges to make different guns shoot. We can't just throw 100 gr of powder in and expect the groups to be phenomenal. This is why so many people curse a brand ammunition, because it don't shoot good with 1 set powder charge, in one gun. Thats why I like muzzleloaders and loose powder, you can tweak shot to shot, without having to go back to the reloading press.
3. Clean-up: Dirty powders lead to fouling and poor accuracy, and just a pain to clean. There is no miracle powder that will keep your barrel clean. 2 reasons: Primers foul, and bullets foul. The powder isn't going to clean up after the primer and bullet.
4. Availability: If it is a hassle to find, what good is that when you want go shoot.
5. Price: This fluctuates depending on how good it is at the 4 prior things, but within reason.
I'm not going to dis any powder that someone uses. If it works for them, thats great!! But it does not mean it works for me. Blackhorn maybe great powder in some guns, but it had constant misfires in 2 written reviews on my Knight Shadow. That with price and availability(I couldn't find it anywhere here in Portland, OR), it is not a good fit for me. Triple 7 has worked great, it just crud rings the barrel. And the JSG has been good so far, but I still need to test it further. Availability is the only factor with the JSG, and I found a place that sells it.