Testing the new Lehigh 40x200 gr, XP

Modern Muzzleloading Forum

Help Support Modern Muzzleloading Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

sabotloader

Keep Shooting Muzzleloaders - They are a Blast
Supporting member
*
Joined
May 19, 2005
Messages
9,205
Reaction score
1,736
As I had planned I was able to get out to the farm mid-morning to do some shooting using the new Lehigh Xtreme Penetrator Brass muzzleloader bullet.

I really should say when I first heard about this new bullet - even when the new bullet was a copper pistol bullet and I think GregK first posted about the new bullet. I was really not that interested or inclined to think a non expanding solid brass or even copper bullet would hold any interest for me. UNLESS, I was considering hunting 'dangerous game'. The 'BULLET' did get more of my attention when I looked on the new Lehigh Web Site and checked out the penetration and wound channel facts that were posted for the pistol bullets. I had/have been shooting regular hollow point pistol bullets in my Sigs - one a 357 sig and the a 40 S&W. I had taken great pains to make sure I was not using a 'Home Defense" type bullet in the pistols that I was carrying in the woods while ML hunting. I wanted a bullet for yotes, wolves, black bear, and maybe even a cougar we have them all. The 'XP' was really what I needed. But, as I gained knowledge about them I thought - maybe a ML bullet of that design just might work.

Cavitation - whom ever mentioned that in one of these threads really opened my eyes - then after reading about 'cavitation' on line and having the bullet in hand looking at the design of the cavities in the nose it started to make sense. So now I need to apologize to Lehigh Dave who told me the straight scoop in the first place.

Today was the first step in the process of testing and checking for me. It was just a straight forward shooting day - just shooting paper. Next I want to do some velocity testing and finally some 'cavitation' testing.

I took two of my 45's to the fame this morning. A normal Knight DISC Extreme with a slow 1-30 twist and a Knight Super DISC with a faster 1-20 twist. Both rifles were scoped one with a Bushnell Elite 3x9 and the other with a Leupold Ultimate Slam 3x9. In addition the Super DISC was set for a near zero at 200 yards for yote and wolf hunting, so it is 3+ inches high @ 100



I set up a target, I ranged from the target back to the pick-up to be 100 yards, and decided to shoot the Super DISC first. Grouse had already done this so I was pretty confident that shooting the 100 would be just fine with the bullet. The only differences were he was shooting BH with a Harvester sabot and I was shooting T7-2f with a MMP sabot. In our discussion Grouse said to be sure and shoot some light powder loads as he had not done that. And as some one else suggested with this bullet it opens up some very good options for soft recoiling loads for those that would like it that way. The bullet will function as designed down to 800 fps and still provide really good penetration. So that was included in the test.

I started shooting 120 grains of T7 and using a MMP light tan sabot...



I shot four shots with that load then started backing the powder load down to 110, 90, 70, and finally 60 grains of powder.

It wasn't the best day to shoot because of the wind... the wind always blows at the farm but today it seemed really hardy, quartering from right to left across the range.

Here is the target - I felt I did very well up until the last shot of the day, a 60 grain shot with absolutely no recoil but I still managed to pull it away from the group... Also at the end of the shoot when I ranged back to the target from the portable bench it read 92 yards... So I labeled the target that way.



92 yards to the target



I did shoot the second rifle, the DISC Extreme, but the 1-30 twist, but it would not stabilize the bullet. All 3 shots did tumble. The solution for that as it has been in the past will probably be a slightly shorter 40x185+/- gr. XP.

Hope this hold some interest for some of you...
 
Question:
My 1-28 50 will shoot the regular 200gr /40 caliber in tight one hole groups does this mean that my 1-28 /45 caliber is likely to shoot this XP 200 grain well?
 
Lee 9 said:
Question:
My 1-28 50 will shoot the regular 200gr /40 caliber in tight one hole groups does this mean that my 1-28 /45 caliber is likely to shoot this XP 200 grain well?

Right now that is the big question - I think it will go in a 1/28 but do not know that as a fact. If everything goes right I plan to run to the farm tomorrow with a 1-28 x 50 cal. and check that. I would say if it works in a 1/28 then Lehigh should go with it - but I am not Lehigh so it will end up being Dave's decision...
 
Looks like it is very accurate on target with the right twist. The videos are pretty impressive. Just when you start getting used to the way the Bloodline works they come up with something else new. The one for the little .380 was very impressive for that light caliber.

Now if Knight will release a new .45 with a 20 twist.
 
TripleSe7en said:
Isn't 1:28 in a vast majority of 45-cal inlines today?


Not sure about most, but Knight still uses the 1 in 30 for the .45 cal. Below is copied from the Mountaineer Page.

"twist rate .45/1:30 in., 50/1:28 in., .52/1:26 in."
 
That is some nice shooting :yeah:


What length is that bullet?

I wonder how much the fins up front slow the bullets rotational velocity compared to a smooth tipped bullet?
 
Very nice shooting... and that design is really different looking. What kind of loading jag do you recommend using on that bullet?
 
cayuga said:
Very nice shooting... and that design is really different looking. What kind of loading jag do you recommend using on that bullet?

I am using my Spin Jag Original with it - it works very well, even the TC Super Jag covers it just fine..
 
BuckDoeHunter said:
That is some nice shooting :yeah:


What length is that bullet?

I thought I had it written down - heck I will just measure it...

.912"

I wonder how much the fins up front slow the bullets rotational velocity compared to a smooth tipped bullet?

You know I have started thinking about the 'nose' of the bullet a lot lately - I really think it has some hidden properties - I really wish I were one of the nerds on 'Big Bang Theory' then I could figure it out!!!
 
As noted in an earlier post the penetration is enhanced by the flat surface on the front on the bullet. The mechanism is called super cavitation. A typical flat point bullet will have a round, flat meplat. If the meplat is a large enough diameter it will create a vapor bubble that will be large enough to form a cavity around the body of the bullet. This vapor cavity effectively eliminates all drag that would be produced by the target medium (liquid and remember flesh is mostly water so this applies to the chest cavity of a game animal). The only drag is from the meplat itself. This is why non-deforming, flat pointed bullets always penetrate further in a liquid medium than do non-deforming sharp pointed bullets. It seems counter intuitive at first but it really is true.

When looking at the "x" shaped damage created by this bullet in ballistic gel, I think we are seeing two things. First the extreme penetration of the bullet is a certain indication that super cavitation is in play here. The "x" shaped wounds look to me to be the result of shock waves emanating from the arms of the X as the bullets travels through the gel.

One other thing to point out is the super cavitation only works in a dense medium like water, ballistic gel, or animal flesh. Pointed bullets are much better in air. Penetration in air is measured in thousands of yards! The military calls it maximum effective range and spitzers have a much longer MER than do blunt bullets.

There was a article several years ago in Scientific American magazine about super cavitation. It seems the Russians developed a 300 mph torpedo! It has a rocket motor instead of screw and a hardened flat meplat to generate the vapor cavity around the body of the torpedo. Thank goodness they never figured out a way to steer or guide the torpedo because there were no fins or rudders in the water to turn it. Had they found a solution it might have instantaneously obsoleted our submarine fleet.
 
Dutch Thank you very much for that explanation. That certainly is not my cup of tea... I go strictly by if I shoot it, hit in the correct spot the animal should drop very quickly. If it does the bullet works,
 
Sabotloader I have to admit that most of the super premium ML bullets never really tempt me too much. Mostly it is due to the cost and the fact that they don't offer added advantage over regular bullets equal to that extra cost. However this XP does seem to be that much better. Given that it doesn't deform or fragment and still has the strong wound channel at low speed really mean that any bullet failure is impossible. I like that! I am going to hunt with them in the fall. I am also going to get some for my 10mm pistol that I carry in the woods.

I am thinking about the 220gr .429 for my 50 cal Knight MK85. It should work wonderfully and have lower recoil. What are your thoughts?
 
Mike ..nice shooting and report also...actually the 90 and 110 grain look very nice...keep up the good work...

I read now you used the .45 ....I cant wait to shoot some when the glaciers reseed here...

keep up the good shooting
Al
 
Kates said:
How do you think that bullet would do in a .44mag handgun?

Really about the same - but, in a handgun you would have to use the Pistol bullet and it will be copper. But I am not sure right now that he is making a 44.

Might check his web site...

http://www.lehighdefense.com/

If it is missing it could be coming in the future...

mike
 
They do offer the ammo in a 220 grain. I typically hunt with a 240 gr soft nose so just a little apprehensive. I will give Lehigh a call to see if they have any actual hunting experience with the handgun ammo. I saw the deer that Carlos killed with a muzzleloader and it definitely puts the hammer on one.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top