dbowling said:
powerbelts basically vaporize when shot with large powder charges, that bullet just flattened out and lost a chunk which would of still been in animal and done damage.. as far as a blood trail single holes will bleed a lot just depends on shot angle/bullet, even on a high shot angle if the lungs are turned to mush the animal will be blowing blood out its nose and mouth leaving a trail most people could follow. Bullets that just pencil thru with little expansion are the ones that generally don't bleed much.. the way that bullet expanded if you hit animal thru vitals you wont need a blood trail as more then likely they wont make it out of sight.
Muley Hunter said:
I don't think it would fail to kill. It probably wouldn't give a pass through and that's important to some guys who need a good blood trail.
Reminds me of the Powerbelt problem.
Let's be fair. The light Powerbelts fall apart. This test is a heavy conical. Let's go apples to apples. The 405gr-444gr Powerbelts hold the muzzleloader grizzly world record. I watched a video of the 444gr knock a water buffalo off its feet.
I'd be comfortable using the 405gr PB for elk. I agree the lighter Powerbelts are pathetic.